FPL
FPL GW4 Captain Picks: Pedro or Palmer?
11 September 2026
FPL Demon

Haaland is off to Old Trafford. Three Chelsea attackers get Hull at the Bridge. And half your mini-league is about to spend Saturday morning arguing Palmer or Pedro. The Demon's run the numbers so you don't have to.
It isn't as close as it looks. Palmer and Pedro are level on expected points, but only one of them is actually getting the chances.
1. Joao Pedro (Chelsea, FWD, £7.7m)

Hull (H).
Already scored at Fulham and at home to Brighton. He blanked against Arsenal with barely a sniff, fair enough. This week the Demon has him on 0.91 expected goals. Nobody else on this list gets near that.
Don't call Hull a free hit, though. Three clean sheets, wins over United and Coventry, a draw with Villa. They're organised. Which is exactly why you want the man finishing the chances, not the one making them.
Demon's Verdict: Home, 90 minutes, £7.7m and the best chances in the building. That's the armband.
2. Cole Palmer (Chelsea, MID, £9.7m)

Hull (H).
The name everyone reaches for, and on expected points he's basically level with Pedro. Look closer. 0.59 expected goals this week against Pedro's 0.91. Over the season he's the quietest shooter of the five: 1.05 expected goals, 2 goals. Brilliant on the ball. Just not the one on the end of it.
Demon's Verdict: Already your Chelsea attacker and you don't fancy burning a transfer? Fine. Given the choice, the Demon goes Pedro.
3. Morgan Rogers (Chelsea, MID, £7.6m)

Hull (H).
Same game, different job. Rogers is the one sliding the passes through, with 1.14 expected assists on the season and only 0.48 expected goals this week.
Demon's Verdict: Lovely player to own. Wrong player to captain with Pedro on the same pitch.
4. Alexander Isak (Liverpool, FWD, £9.1m)

Fulham (H).
The best of the rest. Fulham have already shipped seven, and Isak has 3 goals from 2.29 expected goals this season. He's on 0.66 this week.
The catch: the Demon only sees about 81 minutes in him.
Demon's Verdict: A proper option if you don't own a Chelsea attacker. Just not the one.
5. Erling Haaland (Man City, FWD, £15.5m)
Man Utd (A).
The comfort pick. 3 goals, 2.46 expected goals, every minute played, and City have been the best attack of this lot. He's still only fifth on the Demon's list.
A derby at Old Trafford is not Hull at the Bridge. 0.64 expected goals is fine. Pedro's 0.91 is better.
Demon's Verdict: The best player on the list, in the worst fixture. He can wait a week.
Demon's Final Word
Ignore the name on the shirt. Haaland is the safe one, Palmer is the popular one, and Pedro is the one getting the chances. The Demon is captaining Joao Pedro.
Good luck.



